Fly Creek NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Renovation Opportunity: Cozy modular with an Addition, Unlock the potential of this charming ranch-style home nestled amidst the serene landscape of Fly Creek. While this property requires some work and updating, it offers a unique opportunity to create your dream retreat in the countryside. Step inside and envision the possibilities as you explore the spacious 15x20 family room addition, complete with a gas fireplace, perfect for cozy gatherings or quiet evenings. The home features two bedrooms and two bathrooms. Enjoy the beauty of nature from the 3-season porch, where you can relax and unwind amidst the tranquil surroundings. Step outside onto the back deck and take in the expansive views stretching out before you. Additional features include a poured concrete foundation and a full basement, offering plenty of storage. While some updates are needed, such as a new roof and replacement of the front bay window, recent improvements include a new oil tank, a newer furnace, and an upgraded 200+ amp electrical service, laying the groundwork for modernization. Located only minutes from the Village of Cooperstown. Cooperstown Schools.

Idyllic Fly Creek setting, this historic gem, a circa 1850 Eyebrow Colonial, captivates with its storybook charm. Set against stunning vistas on 7.40+/- acres, this fabulous property boasts a rich legacy, once serving as an Inn along the revered Turnpike, imbued with tales of exceptional stewardship and rumored visits from aviator Amelia Earhart, this cherished estate exudes timeless allure. Meticulously preserved, it showcases a kitchen with vintage accents, a formal living room fireplace, and a family room adorned with antique Cottage Andes woodstove. With original wide pine flooring, doors, and latches, alongside a painstakingly restored post & beam barn, the entire property has perimeter fencing with double gated entry to the extensive circular paved drive and offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of history amidst the picturesque countryside just 2 miles from the village of Cooperstown! This fabulous property is available to view beginning April 2nd, please call and schedule your appointment today.

Charming Cottage in the Cooperstown School District on the outskirts of Fly Creek! This 3+ Bed, 2+ bath home sits on a little over an acre on a corner lot! The home has tons of potential for a primary residence or a possible investment property. Affordable home and taxes! There is a first floor bedroom with private entrance and full bath. A den/office, formal dining room, living room and kitchen complete the downstairs. Upstairs are 2 bedrooms and a full bath. The quaint cottage with rustic flare is situated on a corner lot with road frontage on 2 making it feel like you have a bit of privacy yet conveniently located! The full basement has a workshop and walks out to the attached green house and back yard. The yard is big enough for gardening, entertaining with views of the mountains and nature in the distance. Conveniently located just outside of Cooperstown minutes from Otsego Lake, Baseball Hall of Fame, Dreams Park, restaurants, shopping etc.

First time on the market is this quaint, circa 1880 farmhouse and barn, set on about 2 country acres on both sides of the town maintained, paved road. Heated with two propane stoves, this home offers 4-5 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. The eat-in kitchen is minimal and features a walk-in pantry with its original built-in cupboard. With some imagination and remodeling, the attached wood shed lends itself to additional living space. Outside the lush green lawn is accented with a split rail fence, a smoke house stands alongside the milk house which shelters the drilled well. The blacktop driveway leads to the traditional red barn where horse stalls are still in place. New features are the roof and replacement windows. Step back in time in this adored home on your home search tour. Just minutes to Cooperstown and Oneonta.