The median home value in Sayville, NY is $579,187.
This is
higher than
the county median home value of $490,000.
The national median home value is $308,980.
The average price of homes sold in Sayville, NY is $579,187.
Approximately 65% of Sayville homes are owned,
compared to 17% rented, while
17% are vacant.
Sayville real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale.
Commercial properties are also available.
If you like to see a property, contact Sayville real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Learn more about Sayville.
Single family home, 4 bedrooms 3 full baths and one 1/2 bath. Full finished basement with 10 foot ceilings. In ground pool.
Spectacular, updated waterfront contemporary home in the heart of South Sayville on a cul-de-sac. Floor to ceiling windows, accented by water views in the spacious great room with fireplace and vaulted ceiling, all new eat-in kitchen with quartz counters and Thermodore appliances., custom kitchen cabinets and pantry. 1st. floor bedroom has a full bathroom. 2nd floor features primary suite with jacuzzi tub, walk-in closet and private deck and additional bedroom with ensuite bath. Office space with panoramic views on 3rd level. CAC, New roof. Bulkhead 105 ft. with a jet ski lift. Jacuzzi, New hot tub on a Trex deck. Effortless indoor/outdoor layout to make entertaining an absolute dream. Your home by the water awaits. Minutes away from the Fire Island Beaches
Beautifully located on a peninsula, this architecturally distinctive waterfront home, custom-built in 1982, has unobstructed views of pristine wetlands. The spacious living room with a cathedral ceiling and wood-burning fireplace w heatolater, loft den, updated eat-in kitchen overlooking the canal, and home office with an outside entrance provide versatile living spaces. Boasting 4 bedrooms and 3.5 updated bathrooms, this home seamlessly blends style with practicality. All is enhanced by 100 feet of new Navy bulkheading behind the home AND another 100 feet of the same across the street, providing substantial income to subsidize taxes! It's a wonderful waterfront gem and an investment in the special South Shore lifestyle.
Welcome to this grand, charming colonial-style home boasting 5 bedrooms and 2Full Baths 2 Half Baths, perfectly situated in a serene neighborhood. As you step inside, you're greeted by a spacious layout featuring a formal dining room, ideal for hosting memorable gatherings. Featuring a new eat-in kitchen offers both functionality and style, Beneath the carpet lies stunning hardwood floors, waiting to be revealed and admired. Dual Staircase, Finished basement W/ OSE, 2-car attached garage New windows, roof, boiler, and a separate hot water tank. Embrace the opportunity to make this your dream home, blending classic charm with contemporary amenities.
Completely restored 100 year old farmhouse restored to its original glory with every modern amenity you could wish for. This 6 bed 6 bath home offers new windows, roof , siding ,flooring, air seal foam insulation, HVAC ( 3 zones) , commercial kitchen, steam shower & central vac. Full service maids quarters w/ laundry & kitchen. The home also offers a large front porch, detached barn, master balcony overlooking professionally landscaped grounds of the yard. Through street driveway with possible future subdivision w/ proper permit, complete fencing w/ privacy hedges & irrigation. This really is home sweet home.
This Fire Island Pines Home is One Block From the Ocean W/ A Roof Top Deck W/ Hot Tub & Scenic Views of The Ocean & Bay. 6 Private Bedrooms W/ Private Baths & Balcony! Completely Remodeled, Italian Porcelain Wood Grain Floor Throughout, LED Lighting Throughout, Fujitsu HIVAC Units In Each Room, On Demand Hot Water, Salt Water Pool, Outside Shower, Trex Decking Throughout All Three Floors, Gourmet Kitchen With Thermidor Appliances, High End Spa Suite Primary Bedroom Gas Fireplace W/ Remote Control, Built in Surround Sound & Speakers W/ 4 Zones.
Welcome to this beautiful three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath Colonial retreat just a stroll away from the beach and park. Beyond the inviting entry foyer lies a meticulously maintained residence boasting laminate wood floors and bespoke window treatments in the Living Room and Dining Room. The Family Room, featuring a vaulted ceiling and a dual-sided gas fireplace connecting to the Dining Room, offers a splendid ambiance with oversized windows and a sliding door leading to the patio. Enjoy the modernized eat-in kitchen equipped with cherry cabinets, Silestone countertops, stainless steel appliances, a skylight, and another sliding door to the patio. The Laundry/Mud Area, with outside entry , adds practicality to the space. The Primary bedroom impresses with its vaulted ceiling, gas fireplace, balcony, and custom walk-in closets. Embrace outdoor living on the wrap-around front porch or the stone patio in the private fenced backyard surrounded by lush landscaping. Convenient features include a custom-built shed, a spacious driveway, central air, a new hot water heater with a Weil McLain Boiler, three fireplaces, inground sprinklers, solar panels, and inside entry from the attached garage-Low taxes! This residence is a harmonious blend of comfort, style, and practicality.
597 Cottage Walk is a welcoming retreat tucked into a private enclave of just 3 properties, The open living / dining room & kitchen spills out onto the large pool deck set amid a captivating garden. 3 thoughtfully appointed bedrooms & 3 full baths. Additional amenitie include air conditioning throughout, bluestone patio, outdoor shower and potential for private beach access.
Discover the tranquility of country living in this move in ready 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom Colonial. This delightful home offers a perfect mix of comfort, convenience, and natural splendor. The main floor boasts a spacious layout with a cozy living area, perfect for gatherings or quiet evenings spent by the fireplace. The kitchen exudes charm with granite counters and offers ample cabinet space for storage. One of the property's standout features is its expansive backyard, complete with waterfront access to picturesque Mill Pond. Imagine spending lazy afternoons on the back porch, enjoying the peaceful views of the water and lush greenery. The front porch provides another inviting space, ideal for relaxing and soaking in the beauty of the outdoors. Additional amenities include a brand-new roof, laundry facilities, and a sprinkler system. The driveway accommodates four cars with ease, while a full-size garage offers added convenience. A shed outside provides extra storage space. Situated just 1 mile from Main Street with award-winning schools and so much more. Don't miss out on the opportunity to make this charming home your own.
Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom cottage nestled in the heart of Sayville. With its quaint exterior and cozy interior, this home is the perfect blend of comfort and character. This home offers easy access to local shops, restaurants, parks, and Sayville Schools. Don't miss your chance to make this delightful cottage your new home sweet home.
PRICE ADJUSTMENT. Secluded Water Island Estate. 2 + acres, 200 feet of ocean frontage. Paul Rudolph designed owners pavilion with master bedroom & bath. Open living, dining kitchen. Family room. Separate shingled guest cottage with 2 guest suites opening to large screened-in porch. Large pool & deck. Formal tiered garden. Private bayside boat launch.
Enjoy coastal living in South Sayville with water views and bay breezes! Langcroft Beach Association deeded docking rights and private beach. Living room with gas fireplace, formal dining room, newer kitchen, enclosed porch. Secluded master bedroom on 3rd floor has full bath, walk in closet and bay views. 2nd floor has a full bath, 2 bedrooms and 1 office/bedroom with built-ins. Additional bedroom and full bath on ground floor. Hardwood floors throughout. New roof, solar panels, dry basement system. Large driveway for your boat! Don't miss this opportunity!
Must see! Spectacular unobstructed view of the Great South Bay year-round in Sayville! Spacious open floor plan with sliding doors to a large deck from the living, dining and bedroom. The newly renovated kitchen has quartz countertops and stainless-steel appliances. There is a washer, dryer and central air conditioning in the unit. Hard wood floors throughout. The waterfront common area includes grill, picnic table, gas fire pit, large grassy area, bulkhead with French drains and a kayak storage rack-unit includes a kayak. Close to Fire Island ferries, marina, restaurants, shopping and the train station. Heat, water and real estate taxes are all included in monthly maintenance which does not include a STAR rebate. Furnishings are negotiable.
The iconic mid-century Pyramid house of Fire Island Pines (built 1961) offers the most incredible views across the Fire Island National Seashore from Ocean to Bay, as well as unparalleled privacy. This unique property features top of the line structural construction (galvanzied steel beams) and flawless design and has been featured in the New York Times and other publications. Upstairs the main pyramid includes a great room with 25' ceilings containing a wall of glass overlooking the dunes and the open living/dining/kitchen and a double sided wood burning fireplace. Decks with dining and sitting areas face east (dining) over the dunes and west (sitting) over the pool deck. Downstairs is an oversized primary suite with an enormous bedroom, ensuite bathroom, dfressing room/walk in closet, office, and laundry room. Sliding doors open to the pool deck with a heated pool and hot tub. Across the pool deck are 3 smaller pyramids which comprise 2 bedrooms with a bathroom in between. For investors, this exceptional home also generates spectacular rental income (7% cap rate) over just 6 months of the year. A rare oppotunity to own a beautiful beach house that also produces extraordinary income.
Fully renovated 1963 Horace Gifford design on refined and peaceful Shore Walk. This mid-century gem is sequestered behind mature privet hedges and set back from the walk on an oversized lot for maximum privacy. Four bedrooms (2 en suite) and three bathrooms with central heat and air. Large sunny decks (front and rear) look out to beautiful mature landscaping with spacious outdoor dining, swimming pool, outdoor showers and hot tub. Professional grade kitchen. Move in condition. Very strong rental history.
Welcome to this charming Colonial-style home in the prestigious Sayville School District! This expansive property offers the unique opportunity of a Mother-Daughter setup with the proper permit, providing versatility and convenience for your living arrangements. Upon entering, you'll be greeted by the warmth of the wood floor throughout the house.. The main level boasts a spacious living area with a cozy wood-burning brick fireplace, perfect for gathering with loved ones on chilly evenings. With five bedrooms and two and a half baths, there's ample space for the whole family to spread out and enjoy. The master bedroom offers a serene retreat, while the remaining bedrooms provide comfort and flexibility for guests or family members. Step outside to your private oasis featuring a 16x32 pool with a newer liner and pump, offering endless hours of summertime fun and relaxation. The fully fenced yard ensures privacy and security, while a shed provides additional storage for your outdoor essentials. This home is not only a haven for relaxation but also conveniently located just minutes away from shops, restaurants, the farmers market, and the serene San Souci County Park. With natural gas heat, an updated furnace, and a partial basement, this property offers both comfort and practicality. Don't miss the chance to make this your dream home in an idyllic location, offering the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and charm.
Discover luxurious modern living in this sprawling contemporary home set on nearly half an acre, where sophistication meets comfort. Boasting four generously sized bedrooms and four full bathrooms, the residence welcomes you with soaring cathedral ceilings that enhance the sense of space and light throughout. Generous living space and a large eat in kitchen offer plenty of space for entertaining and the culinarily inclined. A sizable dining area also provides ample space for gatherings. The master bedroom, a sanctuary of relaxation, features an ensuite bath and an expansive walk-in closet. A unique highlight to this home is the bonus in-law or guest suite, complete with a separate kitchen and living area for added privacy. The residence extends its allure outdoors with a vast backyard hosting an above-ground pool, a charming paver patio, and an oversized two-car garage. The immense finished basement provides additional living space, ideal for recreation or entertainment, and TONS of storage space ensures practicality. Conveniently located near town amenities, schools, and public transportation, this property epitomizes contemporary elegance and convenience for the discerning homeowner. A list of improvements and amenities include: Roof replaced in 2020, 200 Amp electric service, Solar Panels and an 8 zone sprinkler system to keep your outdoor space lush. All information deemed accurate but not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Essex Model in the Desirable Sunrise Village Gated Community. This Model is 1046 sq ft 2 Bedroom 1.5 Bathroom Original . 1 car attached garage, tucked away on side Nice Open Courtyard Location. Paver Patio
Do you want to style a home to your preferences? Then this is the home for you. It is the best value in Sayville with 1,780 sq ft and it has so much to offer with new Pella windows (Aug 2023), Water Heater (2022), Front door (Aug 2023), Septic (2020) with cesspool for the laundry, Roof (2016), and Fridge (2018). Natural gas on the street in front of the home. It also boasts a 6+ car driveway, maintenance free decking on the front porch, new front door (Aug 2023), hardwood floors throughout, open concept living room/dining/kitchen with vaulted ceilings and propane gas cooking. The lower level has the potential for mother/daughter with proper permits with an outside entrance to the patio and fully fenced yard, large family room, summer kitchen, full bath, laundry, (bed)room, half garage and storage. This home is a diamond in the rough and waiting for the right owner to update the interior. Located close to the Connetquot State Park, Nature Preserves, and Bayard Cutting Arboretum. Low taxes!!!
This classic Fire Island home is beyond "Adorbs" and exudes warmth and character. Inside you will find 4 bedrooms, with 3 bathrooms that have plenty of natural light . This beautiful pines home features a spa pool, hot tub and roof deck with gorgeous bay views and a well maintained garden that will give you an oasis feeling! It's a place that feels like a comforting retreat and is filled with love and personality.
Harry Bates' ingenious take on a traditional chalet is one of the most distinctive properties in the Pines. The top floor open living / dining plan is perfect for casual beach style living. 3 Bedrooms, 2 baths. Amenities include a large pool deck with terrific cabana with wet bar & gym. Beautiful chefs kitchen, central air and heat and multi tiered decks affording views to the great South Bay.
This property is located on Fire Island Pines. A popular destination known for it's beautiful beaches and vacation homes. The main house has a full kitchen, Living Room/Bedroom with sliders, Full Bath and a Dining Area surrounded with windows. Sliders off kitchen lead to new deck with large heated pool. Cottage separate from the main house has 2 rooms, each have 1 Bedroom and full Bath.Updated throughtout with 200amps and plumbing redone. All Updated to making a comfortable and enjoyable place to stay on FireIsland with heated pool and new deck! It's a perfect spot for relaxation and recreation. The presence of a cottage with 2 additional rooms provide extra space for family or guests. Fire Island is a beautiful destination for those looking for a Beach Front getaway!
Nestled in the Heart of this wonderful paradise! This home offers a slice of heaven on earth. This stunning 4 bedroom, 2.5 Bath residence boasts an open floor plan, modern updates, ductless a/c units, a rooftop deck with breathtaking views and a heated pool. Siding on home is made from Hardie Board. Imagine entertaining with your updated kitchen with Stainless Steel appliances and wet bar, surrounded by large windows, sliding doors to outside decks or maybe just relaxing in the yard with your outdoor shower. This is a retreat from the everyday hustle. Your paradise is waiting!
Looking for CASHFLOW? This 10 BDR, 2 Bath Multi-Family Residence is operated as a rooming/boarding house. Each room has rented for $1K/month. That's a potential GROSS MONTHLY INCOME of $10K! This investment practically prints money! Updated Windows, Roof, Vinyl Siding, H20 Heater & 11 individual high efficiency heat pump/ AC units. Cesspool is updated and maintained. Brand new doors and freshly painted rooms with new flooring being installed. Each room has Its own Electric & Gas meter, thermostat, air conditioner, phone jack and cable. 2 Car Detached Garage Provides Additional Storage That Can Be Shared. A Rare Investment Opportunity That Will Practically Fund Your Retirement. A MUST SEE!